On September 1, a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge dismissed the City of Malibu's claim to the public trail easements on Winding Way and Murphy Way, near Escondido Canyon Park. Nothing about the walk from the Winding Way lot to Escondido Falls changed that day. The parking, the mile of paved road with blind curves and the absence of restrooms past PCH are the same as before. In its statement after the ruling, the City said parking along PCH and unenforced sunset closures were among the reasons it sued in the first place.
For anyone who lives along the Escondido Beach stretch of PCH, this canyon is the closest waterfall hike. The case is decided, but the questions the City raised about the trail have not gone away. The ruling also came just before a rain season that started well ahead of normal.
What the Court Settled in September
The case is City of Malibu v. Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy, Los Angeles County Superior Court No. 26SMCV02052. The Malibu Daily News reported that Judge Michael E. Whitaker ruled for the Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy and the Mountains Recreation and Conservation Authority. According to MRCA's September 1 release, the court sustained the agencies' demurrers and dismissed the City's complaint without leave to amend.
The City filed on April 14. It argued that it took ownership of the easements when Malibu incorporated in 1991. The easements had been granted to Los Angeles County in the late 1980s. The City's theory was that recreational trails count as "county highways" under the state Streets and Highways Code. The judge found that hiking and equestrian trails are a different kind of thing from the roads that law covers. He also found the claim was filed too late, because the City had treated the two agencies as the owners for decades.
The Daily News quoted the judge as calling the City's position a "creative legal argument." He also wrote that its claim of having no notice of who owned the trails "strains credulity."
The agencies' leaders described the ruling as a decision about ownership. In MRCA's release, George Lange, chair of the MRCA Governing Board, said:
"This decision provides clarity about the ownership and management of these public trails and allows us to continue our work protecting these lands and maintaining public access."
In practice, MRCA keeps managing the trail it has managed for decades, and the public easements remain public.
What the City Says the Ruling Did Not Fix
The City published its response on September 3. It called the ruling adverse and said it was "evaluating its options, including appeal." It also said no decision would be made until the City Council had considered the question and directed the City's counsel. The statement said the Council would decide on a course of action "in the coming weeks."
The more useful part of that statement is the City's list of reasons for suing. These are all things a hiker deals with directly:
- Trail users parking along Pacific Coast Highway because the trail has too little parking
- Sunset closures that the City says have gone unenforced
- Vegetation on MRCA-managed land that the City says has not been managed
- Trash along the trails that the City says has not been collected
The City said "the Court's ruling does not change" the conditions that led the Council to act. The statement also said the City is still willing to work with MRCA on trail safety, parking, enforcement of closures and vegetation management.
The lawsuit was about ownership, and the complaints behind it were about parking on PCH and how the trail is run day to day. A hiker from Escondido Beach still deals with both every time, starting at the lot.
The Walk From the Lot, Section by Section
The trail directions come from MRCA's own Escondido Canyon Park page. The park is at 27200 Winding Way, off PCH about a mile south of Kanan Road.
| Section | What MRCA posts | What it means on the day |
|---|---|---|
| Winding Way parking lot | $12 to park. The last restrooms on the route are here, at the PCH lot. | Use the restroom here, because there are none farther on. |
| Paved Winding Way | About a mile on the paved road. MRCA warns of "multiple blind curves" and asks hikers to stay on the trail. | Walk the mile on the road itself, following MRCA's safety warning. |
| Edward Albert Escondido Canyon Trailhead | The sign is at the top of a meadow on the left. The trail drops into the canyon from here. | This is where the dirt trail starts. |
| Escondido Creek crossings | The trail crosses the creek several times. MRCA notes the creek is dry in some seasons. | When the creek is running, the crossings get wetter. |
| Lower falls | About a mile past the trailhead. Public parkland ends here. | This is the end of the public hike. |
| Upper falls | Not open to the public. MRCA asks hikers not to climb, to protect the habitat and avoid serious falls. | Turn around at the lower tier. |
The same page says, "The waterfall is dependent on rainfall, and is minimal or non-existent during dry weather." MRCA describes Escondido Falls as a multi-tiered, 150-foot waterfall, the tallest in the Santa Monica Mountains. In a dry year, you walk two miles of road and canyon and find a limestone wall at the end.
Why This Season Gives the Falls a Better Chance
The new rain season began with more rain than usual by this point. Los Angeles Almanac's rainfall tables show the Santa Monica Airport gauge at 1.09 inches in September and 0.67 inches in October 2026. That makes 1.76 inches through October, compared with a normal of 0.74 inches by that date. Downtown Los Angeles was further ahead, at 1.94 inches through October against a normal of 0.73.
Much of October's rain came in one storm. KTLA reported that by 10 p.m. on October 21, coastal and valley areas of Los Angeles County had received about a quarter to half an inch. Mountain and foothill communities had received half an inch to an inch and a half, and showers were still falling.
Neither of those gauges is in Escondido Canyon, and rain in October does not guarantee water at the lower falls in November. Still, a waterfall that MRCA says depends on rainfall now has about twice the normal rain behind it at this point in the season. That is a better starting point than the dry-weather conditions MRCA warns can leave the falls "minimal or non-existent."
The Days the Gate Stays Closed
Wet weather and wind events both shape the hiking calendar here, and wind has closed the park more often this fall. MRCA closed Escondido Canyon Park, along with Corral Canyon Park, Tuna Canyon Park and its other managed parks, from Thursday, October 15, through Saturday, October 17, during a red-flag warning. It closed all MRCA-managed parks again on Saturday, November 7. That warning ran from 2 a.m. to 6 p.m., and the park was closed for the entire day. MRCA reopened all of its parks on November 8.
Both closures fell on Saturdays, so they cost weekend hikers two of their days. MRCA posts closures on its site, and under the interagency protocol, closures are announced the day before when possible. Checking MRCA's park page on the evening before a weekend hike takes less time than driving to the lot and finding the gate closed.
Mark Gruskin has followed the Winding Way easement case from the filing to the ruling, and it remains a practical question for owners along Escondido Beach. If you would like to talk about how public trail easements and access near your property show up in a title report or a purchase, MalibuMark is glad to have that conversation privately. Let's schedule an appointment.